If you buy ivory, you kill people.
This
is the new reality in an illicit trade responsible for large-scale
human exploitation, government corruption, and the funding of rebel
movements, terrorists, and criminal syndicates around the world.
The
imagery and narrative of the global ivory trade is now well known -
replete with rotting elephant carcasses littering African national
parks, well-tailored ministers and heads of state burning ivory stocks
for the camera, and law enforcement officials smiling in front of ship
containers of seized ivory.
While,
there is no doubt of the many faces of the global ivory trade, there is
one element that is too often overlooked - that of the human toll.
The
human toll of the ivory trade is the negative impact on the individuals
and communities exploited along the chain of custody from Africa, to
Asia, and points beyond. It is not just about elephants.
This
trade is historically and inexorably linked to the exploitation and
enslavement of vulnerable communities in Africa and Asia. It
includes governments and countries sucked deeper into the morass of
corruption, mismanagement, and taxpayer abuse wrought from public
officials supporting criminal interests.
Far reaching implications
It
includes the lives affected by the introduction of other illegal
activities that overlap with the groups and individuals engaged in the
ivory trade - including the trafficking of weapons, drugs and humans.
Like diamonds, gold, coltan or timber; ivory is taking its own place as a conflict resource in sub-Saharan Africa.
International
criminal syndicates, corrupt government officials, and some of the
world's most notorious terrorists and militias are fuelling the global
trade in illegal ivory.
In
2012, an 18-month investigation conducted by the Elephant Action League
(EAL) in collaboration with Maisha Consulting, estimated that the
Somalia based al-Shabab organisation was drawing up to 40 percent of
funds for salaries from ivory smuggling.
Other
groups like the Seleka rebels in the Central African Republic, the
Janjaweed in Sudan and the Lords Resistance Army in central Africa have
all been tied to ivory smuggling as a means to raise funding for arms
and operations. Further, elements of several regional governments in
Africa and Asia have been implicated in facilitating the extraction,
trade, and export of ivory for personal profit.
The
underground ivory supply chain increasingly destabilises already
unstable states, and the growth and sophistication of global smuggling
networks is outpacing international efforts to stop them. At the same
time, the rate of poaching is outpacing the time needed to attempt the
behavioural change - in the primarily Asian consumption markets -
necessary to stop the demand for it.
What
that means, is that in conjunction with new innovative awareness
campaigns in Asia, more action is needed on the ground in Africa to
prevent the negative social, political, and economic impacts that are
derivative of the ivory trade.
Militarising ivory trade
In part, that immediate action must include governments and citizens
from western, African, and Asian states facing the responsibilities of
addressing the human death and exploitation it perpetuates.
Given the increased complexity and militarisation of the trade, new innovative approaches will be required to reduce it.
In conjunction with new innovative awareness campaigns in Asia, more action is needed on the ground in Africa to prevent the negative social, political, and economic impacts that are derivative of the ivory trade. |
This
will demand mitigation strategies that occupy a unique space at the
nexus of the fields of environmental conservation, public policy, peace
and security, counter terrorism, and human rights.
While
certainly challenging, addressing the trade through the lens of the
human toll potentially presents opportunities for the creation of new
tools to pressure necessary policymakers and citizens to take additional
action.
For
instance, building the law enforcement and witness protection capacity
of affected states around the world. Crowd sourcing information through
anonymous whistle-blowing mechanisms like WildLeaks.org
has proven incredibly effective, however, there is a gap in the ability
of states to protect the individuals providing critical information and
act on tip-offs.
Informants must know they can be protected and local and international law enforcement must be able to act immediately.
The
environment of impunity for corrupt state and private sector
individuals involved in the trade is also a fundamental barrier to
mitigation. Exploring tough sanctions on individuals and states involved
in the trade could make the business of ivory more costly for those
involved.
It
was the spike in the value of ivory over the past five years that
exacerbated this problem. It will be correlated losses from the cost of
doing business that will stop it.
In
addition to punitive measures, creating public awareness campaigns
specifically on the human toll in countries like China and Thailand
could go a long way in stemming demand. Showing both governments and
consumers in these states that behind every ivory trinket made and sold
is a trail of human suffering and exploitation in Africa - something
most citizens of those countries are unaware of.
Addressing
the trade through the human angle requires a multi-faceted approach
incorporating all aspects of those impacted. In conjunction with African
and Asian partners it affects our collective security, economic
development and partnership, and obligation to the protection of human
rights and shared history.
So while wildlife and wildlife conservation is the traditional medium
to approach the issue of poaching and trafficking, it is becoming
imperative to develop strategies and campaigns that also put a human
face on the destruction and exploitation globally.
Andrea Crosta is the founder of Elephant Action League and WildLeaks.
Aaron Hall is an East Africa-based independent consultant and adviser to Elephant Action League/WildLeaks.
The ivory trade kills people too
Reviewed by Spencer Reports
on
12:12 pm
Rating:
No comments: